Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Info
titleTobacco domains

DI = TO for Tobacco Product Identifier

SPDEVID = SPTOBID for Sponsor Tobacco Device Identifier

DO/DU = Tobacco Design Parameters (DP)

LB = Tobacco Product Testing (TT)

This is an example for the required tobacco product categorization, property description, and design parameter information in an FDA marketing application for one type of tobacco product Cigarette. There are many more and various types of tobacco products, and their parameters can be found in the in the FDA final rule and guidance documents for tobacco products Premarket Authorization (PMTA) and Substantial Equivalence (SE) Pathways. The applicant submitting for SE and PMTAs should provide test data to include test protocols, quantitative acceptance criteria, data sets, and summary of results as applicable for these parameters.

Tobacco Products (TO) is a study reference dataset that provides a mechanism for uniquely identifying a tobacco product. It is similar to Device Identifiers (DI) in function. The primary purpose of this dataset is to provide a list of the products used in an application or study and to provide identifying information for each product, such as product category type, manufacturer, model (product) name, etc., as applicable. All identifying information is grouped by the Sponsor Tobacco Product Identifier (SPTOBID) (similar to Sponsor Device Identifier (SPDEVID) a consistent variable, that is available for use in other domains where data pertaining to the product may be found.

illustrates the representation of a cigarette product's identifiers and descriptors using the TO domain. Note that this example uses TOSCAT (Subcategory of Tobacco Prod ID Element, a permissible variable) to emphasize and differentiate the 2 distinct types of parameters represented in TO: tobacco product identifiers and tobacco product descriptors. 

Option 1 to address Steve H's suggestion of combining our previous product identifiers and product descriptors into a single dataset. This dataset structure deviates from the norm by adding a units variable (TOVALU). This one may be a tough sell to the CDISC standards development community

Option 2 to address  Steve H's suggestion of combining our  previous product identifiers and product descriptors into a single dataset. This is a more traditional findings dataset structure. Advantages: it doesn't break any rules. 

Show the product descriptors which we would have originally put in a DO-like dataset. Cigarette
Dataset wrap
Nameto
Dataset wrap
Nameto
Rowcaps
All rows:SPTOBID is the Sponsor-defined Tobacco Product Identifier, and serves as the "subject" of all records since these are not (human) subject-level data.
Rows 1-4:Show the records for a tobacco product identifiers that were previously represented in a separate DI dataset
Rows 5-10:Show the product descriptors which we would have originally put in a DO-like dataset. We have added TOVALU to allow for units
Dataset2
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINSPTOBIDTOSEQTOPARMCDTOPARMTOVALTOVALU
1TOB07TOCIG01a1TBPRDCATTobacco Product CategoryCigarette2TOB07TOCIG01a2TBPRSCATTobacco Product SubcategoryFiltered, Combusted3TOB07TOCIG01a3MANUFManufacturerJoes Cigs USA4TOB07TOCIG01a4TRADENAMTrade NameTreetop Menthol King Size5TOB07TOCIG01a5PACKTYPPackage TypeHARD PACK
6TOB07TOCIG01a6PRDQUANProduct Quantity20CIGARETTE
7TOB07TOCIG01a7LENGTHLength86.0mm
8TOB07TOCIG01a8CIRCUMFCircumference26.0mm
9TOB07TOCIG01a9VENTLTNVentilation10.0%
10TOB07TOCIG01a10CHARFLAVCharacterizing FlavorMENTHOL
Rowcaps
All rows:SPTOBID is the Sponsor-defined Tobacco Product Identifier, and serves as the "subject" of all records since these are not (human) subject-level data.
Rows 1-4:Show the records for a tobacco product identifiers that were previously represented in a separate DI dataset
Rows 5-10:
Dataset2
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINSPTOBIDTOSEQ
TOTESTCD
TOPARMCD
TOTEST
TOPARMTOCAT
TOORRES
TOSCAT
TOORRESU
TOVAL
TOSTRESCTOSTRESNTOSTRESUTOCOLSRT
TOVALU
1TOB07TOCIG01a

1

TBPRDCATTobacco Product CategoryNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT IDENTIFIER
Cigarette
Cigarettes
2TOB07TOCIG01a2TBPRSCATTobacco Product SubcategoryNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT IDENTIFIER
Filtered, Combusted
Filtered
, Combusted

3TOB07TOCIG01a3MANUFManufacturerNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT IDENTIFIERJoes Cigs USA
Joes Cigs USA

4TOB07TOCIG01a4TRADENAMTrade NameNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT IDENTIFIERTreetop Menthol King Size
Treetop Menthol King Size

5TOB07TOCIG01a5PACKTYPPackage TypeNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT DESCRIPTOR
HARD PACK
HARD PACK
6TOB07TOCIG01a6PRDQUANProduct QuantityNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT DESCRIPTOR20CIGARETTE
2020CIGARETTE
7TOB07TOCIG01a7LENGTHLengthNEW PRODUCT
DESCRIPTOR86.0mm
PRODUCT DESCRIPTOR
86.0
86.0mm
8TOB07TOCIG01a8CIRCUMFCircumferenceNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT DESCRIPTOR26.0mm
26.026.0mm
9TOB07TOCIG01a9
VENTLTN
VENTLTOTTotal VentilationNEW PRODUCT
DESCRIPTOR10.0%
PRODUCT DESCRIPTOR
10.0
10.0%
10TOB07TOCIG01a10CHARFLAVCharacterizing FlavorNEW PRODUCTPRODUCT DESCRIPTOR
MENTHOL
MENTHOL

The Tobacco Product Design Parameters (DP) represents the manufacturing parameters manufacturing parameter specifications of the cigarette tobacco product as used. The example below intended for use are represented in the PD domain  The following example shows the target, minimum, and maximum values associated with each of 19 23 separate design parameters. These parameters are defined as manufacturing guidelinesspecifications, not characteristics that are determined experimentally.

Note the use of the variable IGDCMPID (Ingredient or Component Identifier) in rows 5-6. This tobacco product had 2 tobacco ingredients with 2 different tobacco cut sizes. IGDCMPID identifies to which tobacco ingredient the cut size applies. IGDCMPID originates in the IT (Tobacco Ingredients) and IN (Non-Tobacco Ingredients) domains. See Section 3.1.3.1, Ingredients and Additives, for more information.

Dataset wrap
Namedppd
Dataset2
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINSPTOBID
DPSEQ
IGDCMPID
DPTESTCD
PDSEQ
DPTEST
PDPARMCD
DPCAT
PDPARM
DPSCAT
PDVALTRG
DPORRES
PDVALMIN
DPORRESU
PDVALMAX
DPSTRESCDPSTRESNDPSTRESUDPCOLSRT
PDVALU
1

TOB07

DP
PDCIG01a


1

LENGTHLength
DESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATION

84

83.5

84.5

mm

TARGET
2TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
2
LENGTHLengthDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATIONmmMINIMUM
CIRCUMFCircumference24.824.625mm
3TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
3
LENGTHLengthDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATIONmmMAXIMUM
TBFLMASSTobacco Filler Mass783753814mg
4TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
4
CIRCUMF
MOISTUREMoisture
Circumference
13
DESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATION
12
mm
14
TARGET
%
5TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a

Burley tobacco

5TOCUTSIZ
CIRCUMF
Tobacco Cut Size
Circumference

22

DESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATION

20

mm
24
MINIMUM

cuts/in

6TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a

Reconstituted tobacco

6
CIRCUMFCircumference
TOCUTSIZTobacco Cut Size

27

25

29
DESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATION

mm

MAXIMUM
7TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a


7VENTLFLT
TBFLMASSTobacco Filler MassDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATIONmg
Filter Ventilation

30

23

37

%

TARGET

8TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
8
TBFLMASSTobacco Filler MassDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATIONmg
TPNPLGTHTipping Paper Length313032mm
MINIMUM
9TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
9
TBFLMASSTobacco Filler MassDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATIONmg
CBPPOR

Cigarette Base Paper Porosity

50

45

55Cu
MAXIMUM
10TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a


10
MOISTUREMoistureDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATION%
CBPPERMCigarette Base Paper Permeability

50

45

55

Cu

TARGET

11TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
11
MOISTUREMoistureDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATION%
CPBPORCigarette Paper Band Porosity100.213Cu
MINIMUM
12TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
12
MOISTUREMoistureDESIGN PARAMETER SPECIFICATION%
CPBPERMCigarette Paper Band Permeability100.213Cu
MAXIMUM
13TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
13
TOCUTSIZTobacco Cut Sizemm or cuts per inch 2

CPBDIFF

Cigarette Paper Band Diffusivity0.050.0010.100cm2/s
TARGET
14TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a


14
TOCUTSIZTobacco Cut Sizemm or cuts per inch 2MINIMUM
CPBWIDCigarette Paper Band Width

7

6.7

7.3

mm

15TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a


15
TOCUTSIZTobacco Cut Sizemm or cuts per inch 2
CPBSPCCigarette Paper Band Space20

19.8

20.2

mm

MAXIMUM

16TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a


16
FLTRVENT
FLTREFFFilter
Ventilation
Efficiency

30

25

35

%

TARGET

17TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a


17DPF
FLTRVENTFilter Ventilation%
Denier Per Filament43.64.4
MINIMUM


18TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a


18
FLTRVENTFilter Ventilation%
TDENIERTotal Denier

30000

29100

30900

g/9000m

MAXIMUM

19TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
19
TPNPLGTHTipping Paper Lengthmm
FLTRDENFilter Density0.12340.1050.1419g/cm3
TARGET
20TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
20
TPNPLGTH
FLTRLGTH
Tipping Paper
Filter Length2524.525.5mm
MINIMUM
21TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
21
TPNPLGTHTipping Paper LengthmmMAXIMUM
FLTPRDRPFilter Pressure Drop605169mm H2O
22TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
22
CIGBPPORCigarette Base Paper Porosity or PermeabilityCORESTA Unit (Cu)
TORODDENTobacco Rod Density0.26780.24370.2919g/cm3
TARGET
23TOB07
DP
PDCIG01a
23
CIGBPPOR
CIGPLGTHCigarette
Base
Paper
Porosity or PermeabilityCORESTA Unit (Cu)MINIMUM24TOB07DPCIG01a24CIGBPPORCigarette Base Paper Porosity or PermeabilityCORESTA Unit (Cu)MAXIMUM25TOB07DPCIG01a25BNDDIFCigarette Paper Band Porosity or Permeability or Band DiffusivityCORESTA Unit (Cu) or cm2/sTARGET26TOB07DPCIG01a26BNDDIFCigarette Paper Band Porosity or Permeability or Band DiffusivityCORESTA Unit (Cu) or cm2/sMINIMUM27TOB07DPCIG01a27BNDDIFCigarette Paper Band Porosity or Permeability or Band DiffusivityCORESTA Unit (Cu) or cm2/sMAXIMUM28TOB07DPCIG01a28CPBNDWIDCigarette Paper Band WidthmmTARGET29TOB07DPCIG01a29CPBNDWIDCigarette Paper Band WidthmmMINIMUM30TOB07DPCIG01a30CPBNDWIDCigarette Paper Band WidthmmMAXIMUM31TOB07DPCIG01a31CPBNDSPCCigarette Paper Band SpacemmTARGET32TOB07DPCIG01a32CPBNDSPCCigarette Paper Band SpacemmMINIMUM33TOB07DPCIG01a33CPBNDSPCCigarette Paper Band SpacemmMAXIMUM34TOB07DPCIG01a34FLTREFFFilter Efficiency%TARGET35TOB07DPCIG01a35FLTREFFFilter Efficiency%MINIMUM36TOB07DPCIG01a36FLTREFFFilter Efficiency%MAXIMUM37TOB07DPCIG01a37DPFDenier Per Filament/filamentTARGET38TOB07DPCIG01a38DPFDenier Per Filament/filamentMINIMUM39TOB07DPCIG01a39DPFDenier Per Filament/filamentMAXIMUM40TOB07DPCIG01a40DENIERDenierg/9000 mTARGET41TOB07DPCIG01a41DENIERDenierg/9000 mMINIMUM42TOB07DPCIG01a42DENIERDenier g/9000 mMAXIMUM43TOB07DPCIG01a43FLTRDENFilter Densityg/cm3TARGET44TOB07DPCIG01a44FLTRDENFilter Densityg/cm3MINIMUM45TOB07DPCIG01a45FLTRDENFilter Densityg/cm3MAXIMUM46TOB07DPCIG01a46FLTRLGTHFilter LengthmmTARGET47TOB07DPCIG01a47FLTRLGTHFilter LengthmmMINIMUM48TOB07DPCIG01a48FLTRLGTHFilter LengthmmMAXIMUM49TOB07DPCIG01a49FLTPRDRPFilter Pressure Dropmm H2OTARGET50TOB07DPCIG01a50FLTPRDRPFilter Pressure Dropmm H2OMINIMUM51TOB07DPCIG01a51FLTPRDRPFilter Pressure Dropmm H2OMAXIMUM52TOB07DPCIG01a52TORODDENTobacco Rod Densityg/cm3TARGET53TOB07DPCIG01a53TORODDENTobacco Rod Densityg/cm3MINIMUM54TOB07DPCIG01a54TORODDENTobacco Rod Densityg/cm3MAXIMUM55TOB07DPCIG01a55Cigarette Paper LengthCIGPLGTHmmTARGET56TOB07DPCIG01a56Cigarette Paper LengthCIGPLGTHmmMINIMUM57TOB07DPCIG01a57Cigarette Paper LengthCIGPLGTHmmMAXIMUM
Dataset wrap
Namett
RowcapsRows 1-4:Row 5:SRow 6:Row 7: Dataset2RowSTUDYIDDOMAINSPTOBIDTTSEQTTREFIDTTGRPIDTTTESTCDTTTESTTTCATTTORRESTTORRESUTTSTRESCTTSTRESNTTSTRESUTTCOLSRT1TOB07TTCIG01a1Tobacco Filler massmg

mg

2TOB07TTCIG01a2Tobacco moisture or Oven Volatiles%%3TOB07TTCIG01a3Tobacco cut sizemm or cuts per inch 2mm or cuts per inch 24TOB07TTCIG01a4Tobacco Rod densityg/cm3g/cm35TOB07TTCIG01a5Filter Ventilation%%6TOB07TTCIG01a6Cigarette base paper Porosity or PermeabilityCORESTA Unit (Cu)CORESTA Unit (Cu)7TOB07TTCIG01a7Cigarette Paper band porosity or permeability or band diffusivityCORESTA Unit (Cu) or cm2/sCORESTA Unit (Cu) or cm2/s8TOB07TTCIG01a8Filter efficiency 1%%9TOB07TTCIG01a9Denier per FilamentDPFDPF10TOB07TTCIG01a10Total Denierg/9000 mg/9000 m11TOB07TTCIG01a11Filter Densityg/cm3g/cm312TOB07TTCIG01a12Filter Pressure Dropmm H2Omm H2O

This images shows the filtration zone where the ventilation occurs.

Image Removed

Question - is this helpful?  Will need permission.  This is from the second reference.

References:

Length535254mm

Finally, the PT domain is used to represent the actual results of testing the manufactured cigarette product for conformance to the tobacco product design parameters shown in PD above. PTCAT is a Required variable and is set to "DESIGN PARAMETER TESTING" for all records here. As described in the PD example, IGDCMPID is also used here to differentiate 2 records of the same test performed on each of 2 different types of tobacco that are ingredients of the tobacco product. Typically, applicants would submit data on each parameter in multiple replicates. For simplicity of review, only 1 replicate per parameter is shown. Note that PTREPNUM (repetition number) = 1 for all rows.

Dataset wrap
Namept
Dataset2
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINSPTOBIDIGDCMPIDPTSEQPTTESTCDPTTESTPTCATPTORRESPTORRESUPTSTRESCPTSTRESNPTSTRESUPTMETHODPTREPNUM
1TOB07PTCIG01a

1

LENGTHLengthDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING

83.9

mm

83.9

83.9

mm
1
2TOB07PTCIG01a
2CIRCUMFCircumferenceDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING24.9mm24.924.9mm
1
3TOB07PTCIG01a
3TBFLMASSTobacco Filler MassDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING779mg779779mg
1
4TOB07PTCIG01a
4MOISTUREMoistureDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING13.1%13.113.1%
1
5TOB07PTCIG01a

Burley tobacco

5TOCUTSIZTobacco Cut SizeDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING22cuts/in2222cuts/in
1
6TOB07PTCIG01a

Reconstituted tobacco

6TOCUTSIZTobacco Cut SizeDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING27mm2727mm
1
7TOB07PTCIG01a
7VENTLFLTFilter VentilationDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING35%3535%
1
8TOB07PTCIG01a
8TPNPLGTHTipping Paper LengthDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING30mm3030mm
1
9TOB07PTCIG01a
9CBPPORCigarette Base Paper PorosityDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING48Cu4848Cu
1
10TOB07PTCIG01a
10CBPPERMCigarette Base Paper PermeabilityDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING50Cu5050Cu
1
11TOB07PTCIG01a
11CPBPORCigarette Paper Band PorosityDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING9.8Cu9.89.8Cu
1
12TOB07PTCIG01a
12CPBPERMCigarette Paper Band PermeabilityDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING10Cu1010Cu
1
13TOB07PTCIG01a
13CPBDIFFCigarette Paper Band DiffusivityDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING0.06cm2/s0.060.06cm2/s
1
14TOB07PTCIG01a
14CPBWIDCigarette Paper Band WidthDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING7.1mm7.17.1mm
1
15TOB07PTCIG01a
15CPBSPCCigarette Paper Band SpaceDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING19.9mm19.919.9mm
1
16TOB07PTCIG01a
16FLTREFFFilter EfficiencyDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING28%2828%
1
17TOB07PTCIG01a
17DPFDenier Per FilamentDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING4.1
4.14.1

1
18TOB07PTCIG01a
18TDENIERTotal DenierDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING29900g/9000m2990029900g/9000m
1
19TOB07PTCIG01a
19FLTRDENFilter DensityDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING0.1112g/cm30.11120.1112g/cm3
1
20TOB07PTCIG01a
20FLTRLGTHFilter LengthDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING25mm2525mm
1
21TOB07PTCIG01a
21FLTPRDRPFilter Pressure DropDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING62mm H2O6262mm H2O
1
22TOB07PTCIG01a
22TORODDENTobacco Rod DensityDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING0.2701g/cm30.27010.2701g/cm3
1
23TOB07PTCIG01a
23CIGPLGTHCigarette Paper LengthDESIGN PARAMETER TESTING53mm5353mm
1

References:

  1. International Organization for Standardization. ISO 9512:2019(en) - Cigarettes — Determination of ventilation — Definitions and measurement principles. ISO; June 2019. Accessed October 15, 2023. https://www.iso.org/obp/ui/#iso:std:iso:9512:ed-3:v1:en
  2. Song M-A, Benowitz NL, Berman M, et al. Cigarette filter ventilation and its relationship to increasing rates of lung adenocarcinoma. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2017;109(12):djx075. https://wwwdoi.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6059254/org/10.1093/jnci/djx075