Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
RequestRelated JIRA IssuesStatusFixed/Updated/Removed from SDTMIG v4.0?
Updated IS example 11 in IG3.4

Status
colourGreen
titleResolved

Status
colourGreen
titleupdate complete

2023-03-06: This example has been updated in IG4.0 by Jordan. SuppIS has been converted to NSIS per SDS request. Also, verified with Diane W, the use of "Multiple" rule here is not appropriate here, concatenated values are fine in ISBTAR.

Below is the updated version of the IS Example 11.

IS Example 11 in the SDTMIG 3.4 needs to be updated to cix SuppIS dataset.

Related JIRA issues: SDS-2553SDS-2563

Discussion with Richard Marshall: https://wiki.cdisc.org/x/-otLCQ

Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Nameis
Rowcaps
Row 1:Shows the detection of immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibody against multiple animal allergens
. ISBDAGNT is used to house the generic but controlled value "ANIMAL MIX ANTIGENS"
.
Rows 2-3:Show the amount of IgE antibody against dog dander and its RAST classification score.
Rows 4-5:Show the amount of IgE antibody against cat dander and its RAST classification score.

Rows 6-7:

Show the amount of IgE antibody against horse dander and its RAST classification score.
Rows 8-9:Show the amount of IgE antibody against cow dander and its RAST classification score.
Row 10:Shows immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibody against multiple tree pollen allergens is not detected.
1
Dataset2
Dataset2
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINUSUBJIDIDVARIDVARVALQNAMQLABELQVALQORIGQEVAL
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINUSUBJIDISSEQISGRPIDISREFIDISTESTCDISTESTISBDAGNTISTSTDTLISORRESISORRESUISSTRESCISSTRESNISSTRESUISSPECISMETHODVISITNUMVISITISDTC
1XYZISXYZ12341112453333ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyANIMAL MIX ANTIGENS
POSITIVE
POSITIVE

SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
2XYZISXYZ12342212456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

DOG DANDER ANTIGEN


0.12U/mL0.120.12U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
3XYZISXYZ12343212456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

DOG DANDER ANTIGEN

RAST SCORE0
00
SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
4XYZISXYZ12344312456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

CAT DANDER ANTIGEN


0.19U/mL0.190.19U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
5XYZISXYZ12345312456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

CAT DANDER ANTIGEN

RAST SCORE0
00
SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
6XYZISXYZ12346412456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyCOW DANDER ANTIGEN
44U/mL4444U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
7XYZISXYZ12347412456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyCOW DANDER ANTIGENRAST SCORE4
44
SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
8XYZISXYZ12348512456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyHORSE DANDER ANTIGEN
120U/mL120120U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
9XYZISXYZ12349512456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyHORSE DANDER ANTIGENRAST SCORE6
66
SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Namesuppis
10XYZISXYZ1234
ISSEQ
10
1

12458888
ISTARAGTarget AntigenMULTIPLECRF2XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1ISTARAG1Target Antigen 1DOG DANDERCRF3XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1ISTARAG2Target Antigen 2CAT DANDERCRF4XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1ISTARAG3Target Antigen 3HORSE DANDERCRF5XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1ISTARAG4Target Antigen 4COW DANDERCRF
Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Namesuppis
Dataset2RowSTUDYIDDOMAINUSUBJIDIDVARIDVARVALQNAMQLABELQVALQORIGQEVAL1XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1ISALGREGAllergen Mixture RegionCENTRAL CA, AREA 14CRF

Richard's comments were that if you were to use the "MULTIPLE" convention in IS row 1 as appeared in the original example, ISBDAGNT= ANIMAL MIX ANTIGENS, MULTIPLE, then the suppIS dataset was created incorrectly. "MULTIPLE" requires QNAM to be xxx1-4. So if we want to keep the "MULTIPLE" in binding agent IS row 1, QNAM must be ISBDAG1-4.

However since the panel allergy results can also be reported by the region (as regional mixes), this ISBDAGNT= ANIMAL MIX ANTIGENS, MULTIPLE, doesn't make sense because this also implies multiple regions are associated with a single record, when in fact the IS row 1 record only indicates one region. So it is best to take the word "MULTIPLE" out of ISBDAGNT IS row 1.

Lastly, it seems odd to have dog, cat, horse, cow in QVAL because the panel antibody test targets dog dander, cat dander, horse dander, cow dander. QVAL values are imprecise and should be updated
ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyTREE MIX POLLENS
NEGATIVE
NEGATIVE

SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20

The NSIS dataset below shows the specific and individual animal and tree pollen allergens within the mixed antigens panel tests. Users may wonder why the SDTM "MULTIPLE" convention is not used in the records below, this is because the tests are not "check/select some or all that apply" scenario. The allergen panel tests look for antibodies that target multiple allergens in the below dataset all at the same time and in a single analysis, and the outcome of the assessment is a pooled positive or negative result (IS dataset above rows 1 and 10). Therefore, all the targeted allergens are mapped to ISABTR and are separated with a semicolon.

ARIGEAB
Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Nameisnsis
Rowcaps
Row 1:Shows the detection of immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibody against multiple animal allergens. ISBDAGNT is used to house the generic but controlled value "ANIMAL MIX ANTIGENS".
Rows 2-3:Show the amount of IgE antibody against dog dander and its RAST classification score.
Rows 4-5:Show the amount of IgE antibody against cat dander and its RAST classification score.

Rows 6-7:

Show the amount of IgE antibody against horse dander and its RAST classification score.
Rows 8-9:Show the amount of IgE antibody against cow dander and its RAST classification score.
Dataset2
RowSTUDYID
DOMAIN
RDOMAINUSUBJID
ISSEQ
IDVAR
ISGRPIDISREFIDISTESTCDISTESTISBDAGNTISTSTDTLISORRESISORRESUISSTRESCISSTRESNISSTRESUISSPECISMETHODVISITNUMVISITISDTC
IDVARVALISABTR
1XYZISXYZ1234
1
ISSEQ1
12453333
Allergen-induced IgE AntibodyANIMAL MIX ANTIGENS, MULTIPLEPOSITIVEPOSITIVESERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-202XYZISXYZ12342212456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

DOG DANDER ANTIGEN

0.12U/mL0.120.12U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-203XYZISXYZ12343212456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

DOG DANDER ANTIGEN

RAST SCORE000SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-204XYZISXYZ12344312456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

CAT DANDER ANTIGEN

0.19U/mL0.190.19U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-205XYZISXYZ12345312456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE Antibody

CAT DANDER ANTIGEN

RAST SCORE000SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
DOG DANDER ANTIGEN; CAT DANDER ANTIGEN; HORSE DANDER ANTIGEN; COW DANDER ANTIGEN
6XYZISXYZ1234
6
ISSEQ
412456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyCOW DANDER ANTIGEN44U/mL4444U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-207XYZISXYZ12347412456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyCOW DANDER ANTIGENRAST SCORE444SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-208XYZISXYZ12348512456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyHORSE DANDER ANTIGEN120U/mL120120U/mLSERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-209XYZISXYZ12349512456666ARIGEABAllergen-induced IgE AntibodyHORSE DANDER ANTIGENRAST SCORE666SERUMRIA1SCREENING2018-06-20
10BOX ELDER POLLEN; OLIVE TREE POLLEN; SILVER BIRCH POLLEN
Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Namensis
Definexmltable
DatasetNSIS
NameISABTRG
VariableLabelTypeCodelistRole
ISABTRGAntibody TargetChar
Non-Standard Qualifier

Alternatively, instead of reporting the specific components of a mixed allergen panel, regional allergen mixes may also be reported by the specific regions/areas where they are predominant, as shown in the NSIS dataset below.

Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Namensis
QEVAL
Dataset2
RowSTUDYID
DOMAIN
RDOMAINUSUBJIDIDVARIDVARVAL
QNAMQLABELQVALQORIG
ISALGREG
1XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1
ISBDAG1Binding Agent 1DOGCRF
CENTRAL CA, AREA 14
2XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ
1ISBDAG2Binding Agent 2CATCRF3XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1ISBDAG3Binding Agent 3HORSECRF4XYZISXYZ1234ISSEQ1ISBDAG4Binding Agent 4COWCRF
10SOUTHERN FL, AREA 3
Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Namensis
Definexmltable
DatasetNSIS
NameISALGREG
VariableLabelTypeCodelistRole
ISALGREGAllergen Mixture RegionChar
Non-Standard Qualifier