Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
RequestNotesStatusFixed/Updated/Removed from SDTMIG v4.0?
Need help modeling High-risk Multi-HPV Tpes Screening Test

At the request of Daniel Sinnett and Kathleen Hectors

.

Also need a mechanism to model further identification tests for a previously detected microorganism. There is currently a gap in modeling this type of concepts, and MBTEST = Microbial Organism Identification is inapproeiate for this type of tests.

Status
colourGreen
titleResolved

Status
colourGreen
titleUpdate complete

2023-03-06:

  1. Example is been added to IG4.0.
  2. Talked to Diane W and the concatenated values are fine in the NSVs, the SDTM MULTIPLE rule does not apply here.

Introduction

Persistent infection with Human Papillomavirus (HPV) is the main cause of cervical cancer and is a precursor to cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). HPV is a nonenveloped, double-stranded DNA virus, and more than 150 different types of HPV have been identified. A subset of these types is considered high-risk ( for the development of cervical cancer and its precursor lesions, and is routinely screened clinically in the context of cervical cancer prevention. The HPV test data modeled in this example represent a class of commercially available assays that are able to screen and detect multiple types of high-risk HPV from a subject specimen in a single analysis. https://www.uspharmacist.com/article/human-papillomavirus-cervical-cancer-and-prevention

...

Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Namemb
Rowcaps
Rows 1-3:

Show detection of HPV viral DNA. This test specifically detects HPV type 16 and type18 (rows 2-3) while concurrently detecting 11 other high risk types, 31, 33, 35, 39, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 66 and 68. This test does not differentiate the different types of 31, 33, 35, 39, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 66 and 68, and row 1 record provides a pooled result.

Row 4:Shows the detection of E6/E7 HPV viral messenger RNA (mRNA).  This test detects 12 high-risk HPV types, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 66 and 68, but is unable to differentiate between the HPV types.
Dataset2
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINUSUBJIDMBSEQMBGRPIDMBTESTCDMBTESTMBTSTDTLMBCATMBORRESMBSTRESCMBMETHODVISITNUMVISITMBDTC
MBMOTRGMBMAGTRG
1ABCMBABC-00111HRHPDNMHigh-Risk HPV Types DNA, MLTTRGDETECTIONMICROBIOLOGYPositivePositivePOLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION2VISIT 12018-06-01
HPV Type 31; HPV Type 33; HPV Type 35; HPV Type 39; HPV Type 51; HPV Type 52; HPV Type 56; HPV Type 58; HPV Type 59; HPV Type 66; HPV Type 68
2ABCMBABC-00121HPV16HPV Type 16

DETECTION

MICROBIOLOGYPositivePositivePOLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION2VISIT 12018-06-01


3ABCMBABC-00131HPV18HPV Type 18DETECTIONMICROBIOLOGYPositivePositivePOLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION2VISIT 12018-06-01


4XYZMBXYZ-0011

HRHPMRNM

High-Risk HPV Types mRNA, MLTTRGDETECTIONMICROBIOLOGYPositivePositivePOLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION2VISIT 12018-06-01
HPV Type 31; HPV Type 33; HPV Type 35; HPV Type 39; HPV Type 45; HPV Type 52; HPV Type 56; HPV Type 58; HPV Type 59; HPV Type 66; HPV Type 68

HPV E6 mRNA; HPV E7 mRNA

Nsvmeta
DomainMB
VariableLabelTypeRoleOrigin
MBMOTRG

Multi-Microorganism Test Targets

textNon-Standard Record QualifierCRF
MBMAGTRGMulti-Antigen Test TargetstextNon-Standard Record QualifierCRF

...

Dataset wrap
titlelb.xpt
Namemb
Rowcaps
Row 1:Shows the detection of viral DNA for a pre-specified group of high-risk HPV types (31, 33, 35, 39, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 66 and 68), note the multiple pre-specified HPV types are mapped to MBMOTRG.
Rows 2-4:

Show the further identification of the individual high-risk HPV types from the pre-specified group in row 1.

Dataset2
RowSTUDYIDDOMAINUSUBJIDMBSEQMBGRPIDMBTESTCDMBTESTMBTSTDTLMBCATMBORRESMBSTRESCMBMETHODVISITNUMVISITMBDTC
MBMOTRG
1ABCMBABC-00111HRHPDNMHigh-Risk HPV Types DNA, MLTTRGDETECTIONMICROBIOLOGYPositivePositiveREVERSE TRANSCRIPTASE PCR1SCREEN2018-06-01
HPV Type 31; HPV Type 33; HPV Type 35; HPV Type 39; HPV Type 51; HPV Type 52; HPV Type 56; HPV Type 58; HPV Type 59; HPV Type 66; HPV Type 68
2ABCMBABC-00121HRHPDNMHigh-Risk HPV Types DNA, MLTTRGIDENTIFICATIONMICROBIOLOGYHPV type 31HPV type 31REVERSE TRANSCRIPTASE PCR1SCREEN2018-06-01
HPV Type 31; HPV Type 33; HPV Type 35; HPV Type 39; HPV Type 51; HPV Type 52; HPV Type 56; HPV Type 58; HPV Type 59; HPV Type 66; HPV Type 68
3ABCMBABC-00131HRHPDNMHigh-Risk HPV Types DNA, MLTTRGIDENTIFICATIONMICROBIOLOGYHPV type 52HPV type 52REVERSE TRANSCRIPTASE PCR1SCREEN2018-06-01
HPV Type 31; HPV Type 33; HPV Type 35; HPV Type 39; HPV Type 51; HPV Type 52; HPV Type 56; HPV Type 58; HPV Type 59; HPV Type 66; HPV Type 68
4ABCMBABC-00131HRHPDNMHigh-Risk HPV Types DNA, MLTTRGIDENTIFICATIONMICROBIOLOGYHPV type 66HPV type 66REVERSE TRANSCRIPTASE PCR1SCREEN2018-06-01
HPV Type 31; HPV Type 33; HPV Type 35; HPV Type 39; HPV Type 51; HPV Type 52; HPV Type 56; HPV Type 58; HPV Type 59; HPV Type 66; HPV Type 68
Nsvmeta
DomainMB
VariableLabelTypeRoleOrigin
MBMOTRG

Multi-Microorganism Test Targets

textNon-Standard Record QualifierCRF

New Variable Proposal

Variable NameVariable Label TypeRoleVariable(s) QualifiedUsage RestrictionDefinitionNotesExamplesControlled?

--MOTRG


Multi-Microorganism Test Targets

CharVariable Qualifier

Test Qualifier

MB

A textual description that identifies the multiple pre-specified, targeted microorganisms and their variants being detected.

For the MB domain, this variable is used to describe the multiple specific microorganisms and their variants being detected.

Multiple species from the same genus; multiple variants, serotypes, types, strains from the same species. This variable is used to describe "multiple" organisms being detected in a single analysis.No, free text.

--MAGTRG


Multi-Antigen Test Targets

CharVariable QualifierTest QualifierMBA textual description that identifies the multiple pre-specified, targeted microbial antigens being detected.For the MB domain, this variable is used to identify the multiple specific microbial genes, proteins, toxins, mRNAs, etc., being detected.

When MBTEST = E. coli DNA, MBMAGTRG = IpaH gene; aatA gene

When MBTEST = HPV mRNA, MBMAGTRG = HPV E6 mRNA; HPV E7 mRNA


No, free text.

Impact on Controlled Terminology

  1. Existing multi-target MBTESTs: NO deprecation.
  2. New multi-target MBTEST requests: the MB team will continue to create new, pre-coordinated, multi-target tests when the team can fit all the targets into the MBTEST and the TEST is **meaningful**.
    1. CT rules on a "meaningful" pre-coordinated MBTEST:
      1. The MBTEST should clearly describe the microorganism(s) being assessed, either using full taxonomic name or scientifically accepted acronym/abbreviation.
      2. The MBTEST should clearly describe the antigenic target(s) using scientifically accepted full name or acronym/abbreviation.
      3. If excessive abbreviation/truncation is required to fit all targets into the MBTEST which makes the test less human-readable (and in turn a less useful SDTM mapping asset), or users are required to rely on the spelled-out CDISC synonyms to understand the intent of the value in MBTEST, a pre-coordinated MBTEST should be avoided.
      4. It is the MB team's responsibility to determine meaningfulness for a pre-coordinated MBTEST and whether or not to develop controlled tests, on a case by case basis. If the MB team is unable to develop a meaningful MBTEST, the team will provide mapping recommendations in the denied request message.
  3. The post-coordination, additional variable approach will be recommended when a pre-coordinated and meaningful MBTEST is not possible, as in the case of the HPV multi-target test.
    1. CT Rules on post-coordinated MBTEST:
      1. The MBTEST should describe, on a high-level, and to the team's best ability, the overall type or taxonomic grouping commonality (if available) of the microorganism(s) being detected. Examples: MBTEST = HPV Type DNA (when the asseemsnet detects HPV Type 22+45+18+16+58+66 DNA); MBTEST = Coronavirus RNA (when the assessment detects SARS-related Coronavirus RNA+MERS RNA); MBTEST = Campylobacter DNA (when the test detects Campylobacter aviculae+Campylobacter bilis+Campylobacter corcagiensis+Campylobacter gracilis).
      2. For MBTEST, the abbreviation "MLTTRG (short for Multi-Target)" should be added to the end of the MBTEST, e.g. Coronavirus RNA, MLTTRG. For MBTESTCD, the letter "M" (which is equivalent to MLTTRG) is used at the end of the TESTCD, e.g. HRHPDNM.
      3. When "MLTTRG" appears in the MBTEST, this indicates a test that targets multiple microorganism(s) and/or microbial antigen(s) which have been post-coordinated. Users should map the specific multiple targets to --MOTRG and/or --MAGTRG.
      4. For unrelated multiple targeted microorganisms or when taxonomic commonality is difficult to determine, a generic MBTEST such as Bacteria, MLTTRG; Virus, MLTTRG, may be created. Example: MBTEST = Bacteria, MLTTRG (when test detects Shigella spp+Campylobacter spp+Clostridium difficile+EIEC+ETEC).

...